The Unintended Consequences: How Law and Crime Are More Connected Than You Think
- Ethan T.
- Apr 23, 2023
- 2 min read
law and Public Policy

As someone who has a vested intrest in the legal profession for some time, I have become particularly intrigued by how law and criminal activity intertwine. It cannot be denied that laws have tremendous influence over both individual behavior as well as larger societal conduct. However, it is worth noting that their impact on crime rates can often prove elusive or unpredictable at best. The purpose of this paper is to investigate how certain legislation may indirectly promote unlawful activities and perpetuate criminal behavior over an extended period.
An exploration of the interlacing and multifaceted relationship between law and crime is crucial. These regulations are created to impede illegal behavior, inflict severe penalties upon wrongdoers whilst also preventing further criminal activity; however, it's equally important to consider that unlawful actions can arise as a response against specific rules set by economic or political influences or even societal standards.
In the first decade of the 1900s, a ban on alcohol in America led to an increase in crime rates. A portion of Americans perceived this as their chance for financial gain from bootlegging alcoholic beverages.
Despite the ban on alcohol being set with good intentions to increase the wellbeing of the country, it has only served to increase crime rates. On occasions, well-intentioned regulations can lead to an increase in unlawful behavior if they are not properly implemented or appear to favor one group over others.
Even with notable improvements built onto the legal system to relieve discrimination racial and ethnic bias against certain communities with darker skin tones exist subconciously through culture and upbringing.
In addition to the "three strikes" ruling, there are numerous cases where laws have been instituted with unintended consequences. A notable example is the promotion of law enforcement's "broken windows" which involves tackling minor offenses like loitering or vandalism in order to prevent more serious crimes.
Although the theory initially seemed plausible, subsequent research has revealed an increase in detentions due to minor offenses disproportionately affecting those from low-income and minority communities. Additionally, the increased presence of law enforcement officials in these areas has resulted in a society plagued by uneasiness and uncertainty which ultimately fosters criminal activity.
In conclusion, the complex and multifaceted relationship between laws and criminality is not a simple issue. Despite regulations being implemented to limit illegal conduct, their impact on crime rates often remains unclear. In certain situations, legislation can even have adverse effects by provoking more unlawful actions, particularly affecting minority populations.
It is therefore paramount for individuals in the legal profession and those in positions of governance to take into account the potential repercussions that could result from new laws. Through prioritizing the protection of each person within a community throughout the laws development and execution. This tactic serves as an important foundation toward creating a stable atmosphere where equity reigns supreme for all relevant parties involved.
Comments